A Formal Model of Phonological Typology
نویسنده
چکیده
One of the most contested debates in phonology concerns identifying factors that affect typology. Two lines of thought emerge in this discussion: Analytic Bias (AB) and Channel Bias (CB) approach (Moreton, 2008). The AB approach claims that cognitive biases in learning influence the typology, while the CB approach assumes phonetic precursors and transmission of language affect the typology (Moreton, 2008). Both approaches are supported by empirical evidence. Phonological processes that are typologically rare have been shown to be more difficult to learn or their learning requires more input data (e.g. Wilson, 2006; White, 2014, and many others; for a survey, see Moreton & Pater, 2012a,b). On the other hand, processes that result from phonologization of phonetically motivated sound changes with clear phonetic precursors are also typologically more frequent (Blevins, 2004). While an increasing body of work acknowledges that both AB and CB influence the typology (Moreton, 2008), very few attempts have been made to model the two approaches together: research either focuses on one or the other factor (Blevins, 2004; Kiparsky, 2006; Wilson, 2006; White, 2017, i.a.). This paper aims to fill this gap and proposes a model of phonological typology that models both AB and CB influences together. I argue that this unified model performs better in deriving the surface typology and has an advantage over the current “split” models in that it encodes not only that some processes are rare and others more frequent, but also why such typological differences arise. The first step in the direction of the new typological model are quantitative models of the two sub-components: AB and CB. While several attempts have been made to quantify and model learning of phonology (AB; Wilson, 2006; White, 2017), quantitative approaches to CB have received less attention. The most recent attempt in Cathcart (2015) is computationally too demanding and fails to provide implementable quantitative results. In the first part of this paper, I present and expand on a new model of typology within the CB approach that introduces the concept of Historical Probabilities of Alternations (Pχ ) (from Beguš, 2016). In the second part, I propose a model of typology that admits both CB and AB and employs the Maximum entropy probability distribution over candidates (Goldwater & Johnson, 2003) to derive typological probabilities. The new model of typology combines Historical Probabilities of Alternations introduced here with the learnability metric adapted from Wilson (2006) and unifies them in an MaxEnt-compatible framework.
منابع مشابه
What is Phonological Typology?
In this talk I am concerned with the following questions: 1. What is phonological typology? 2. How are phonological typology and phonetic typology the same/different? 3. How are phonological typology and general phonology the same/different? 4. How are phonological typology and general typology the same/different? Despite earlier work by Trubetzkoy, Jakobson, Martinet, Greenberg and others, and...
متن کاملPost-Nasal Devoicing and a Probabilistic Model of Phonological Typology
This paper addresses one of the most contested issues in phonology: the derivation of phonological typology. I argue that the unnatural process of postnasal devoicing does not derive from a single unnatural sound change, but rather from a combination of two or three sounds changes, each of which is natural and well-motivated. Evidence from both historical and dialectal data is brought to bear t...
متن کاملTypology of the "Internal Form-Structure" Drawing upon Argan's Formal Approach (Case Study: Historical Bridge-Caravanserai in Iran)
In the process of defining the nature of architecture, three elements recur which are indispensable components of architecture: type, function, and structure. The three can be related to the three attributes produced by Vitruvius, i.e. strength, utility, and beauty. The findings of contemporary research on the discourse of typology indicate numerous contradictions between various definitions ...
متن کاملAn Analysis on Formal Typology of Metropolitan Contemporary Housing of Tokyo (by Emphasis on 50 Residential Houses in the City of Tokyo)
متن کامل
What is Reduplication? Typology and Analysis Part 1/2: The Typology of Reduplication
Reduplication has played a central role in the development of phonological theories for 30years. The introduction of Classical Optimality Theory (OT) in the 1990s sparked intensive research into the typology and analysis of reduplicative patterns, as reduplication was a key testing area both for OT and for theories critical of OT. Now, after some 20years of research within the OT model, it is a...
متن کامل